TRUTH. ACCURACY. OBJECTIVITY

GRS, Warisan want wider PAC probe as Pan Borneo blame game intensifies

Kota Belud MP has written a letter to PAC to widen probe on Pan Borneo PDP, after a GRS leader say they will hand over memorandum for the same purpose

The political dispute between Gabungan Rakyat Sabah (GRS) and Warisan over delays in the Pan Borneo Highway has taken a new turn, with representatives from both sides calling for a wider investigation by Parliament’s Public Accounts Committee (PAC).

While GRS wants the committee to examine the 2019 termination of the project’s delivery partner (PDP) model, Warisan leaders are pushing for scrutiny of the entire project, including its original contracts, payments, contractor appointments and land compensation.

The latest move came from Warisan’s Kota Belud MP Isnaraissah Munirah Majilis, who wrote to PAC chairman Mas Ermieyati Samsudin seeking an expanded investigation.

She shared the letter on Facebook on Monday, a day after seven GRS MPs announced plans to submit a similar memorandum.

Papar MP and GRS secretary-general Armizan Mohd Ali said the termination of the PDP arrangement on Sept 22, 2019, following a recommendation by the Sabah administration at the time, should be investigated as one of the causes of delays.

He said uncertainty over the PDP’s status and contractor appointments following the change of government in May 2018 had disrupted construction for more than a year, while some Phase 1A contractor appointments were only completed in 2021.

“So this is not political talk or political issues determined by people, but an official response in the Dewan Rakyat,” Armizan said, referring to Works Ministry replies identifying the PDP termination as one of the factors behind the delays.

On Sunday, he said the GRS MPs would be submitting a memorandum to the PAC.
RELATED LINK:

He said the GRS memorandum would ask the PAC to examine the reasons for the termination and its consequences, including rising construction costs.

Earlier on Monday, Warisan president Mohd Shafie Apdal welcomed the proposal but said the investigation must go beyond the termination decision.

“I welcome it. The people of Sabah want comprehensive answers, not selective ones,” he said.

Shafie wants the PAC to examine the federal Cabinet’s decision on Dec 19, 2018, to terminate the PDP agreement, as well as RM700.99 million paid to Borneo Highway PDP Sdn Bhd (BHPSB) and a separate RM155 million one-off settlement agreed after the termination.
RELATED STORY:

In a parliamentary reply on Oct 28, Works Minister Alexander Nanta Linggi disclosed that the RM700.99 million comprised RM66.917 million in management fees and RM634.073 million in reimbursable expenses, including RM448.36 million paid to consultants.

The RM155 million settlement was agreed by the Cabinet following claims by BHPSB, with a settlement agreement signed on March 3, 2022.

in her letter to the PAC, Isnaraissah wants the PAC to establish the basis of the settlement, whether deductions were made for delays or cost overruns, and when the payment was made. She also wants a breakdown of consultancy payments and details of the work delivered.

The Kota Belud MP further cited the 2019 Auditor General’s Report, which found that all 10 bidders for the Lahad Datu Bypass package failed to meet at least one minimum qualification requirement.

The selected contractor did not meet the minimum annual revenue requirement of RM50 million, had no road construction experience and lacked the required technical staff and equipment.

She wants the PAC to determine whether similar weaknesses affected other contractor appointments and summon the relevant tender committee members.

The two Warisan leaders have also raised questions about the PDP’s ownership and possible connections involving political figures, consultants and subcontractors.

Other issues raised by Isnaraissah include 19 work packages that allegedly began construction before environmental impact assessment approval and the reported loss of 77,299 project monitoring files in December 2023.

She also questioned why Sarawak’s Pan Borneo project received financing through Danainfra Nasional Bhd and whether similar arrangements had been considered for Sabah.

Land compensation is another contentious issue.

Figures cited from the Auditor General’s Report showed Sabah had acquired 2,237.966 hectares involving 6,513 landowners, with RM1.447 billion in compensation, of which RM1.219 billion had been paid by March 31, 2026.

Sarawak acquired 2,373.82 hectares involving 15,968 landowners, with RM700 million allocated and RM681.13 million spent.

Shafie and Isnaraissah want the PAC to investigate the apparent difference in compensation costs, although Isnaraissah acknowledged that land types, locations and valuation methods may differ between the two states.

The controversy centres on the decision to end the PDP arrangement, which was originally introduced to coordinate project delivery.

The federal Cabinet terminated it on national interest grounds after a recommendation from the Sabah government led by Shafie.

GRS has since argued that the decision disrupted construction and contributed to higher costs.

Warisan, meanwhile, maintains that the final decision rested with the federal government and insists that the original project arrangements and payments must also be examined.

Shafie’s earlier criticism of the PDP’s management fee, which was set at 5.5%, and questions over contractor selection have added another dimension to the dispute.

The PAC agreed on Oct 19 to investigate the management, financial governance and physical implementation of Sabah’s Pan Borneo Highway following the Auditor General’s Report Series 2/2026.

The competing demands from GRS and Warisan now place pressure on the committee to examine decisions made under successive federal and state administrations.

Related

Scroll to Top